Project

General

Profile

Actions

Errata #20

open

Difficulty altering weapons obsolete.

Added by Nickademus over 3 years ago. Updated over 3 years ago.

Status:
Pending
Priority:
Low
Category:
Boons

Description

Weapons that let you ignore effects that increase the difficulty of a check (Adamantite weapons, notably) almost never work against post-Core cards. In particular, they prevented "Veteran" monsters from scaling pre-Core, but they explicitly don't prevent the Veteran scaling post-Core as, apparently, it's not an "effect". This is mostly a balance issue, but I also argue that the rulebook doesn't really define what an "Effect" is or isn't.


Checklist

  • Describe current behavior
  • Possible insight from Keith
  • Describe desired behavior
  • Draft final wording
  • Content Review approval
  • FAQ entry created
Actions #1

Updated by Nickademus over 3 years ago

There are still effects in post-Core cards that increase difficulty (such as Boggard and Werewolf). But if this is considered not enough to validate the power of an adamantine weapon, the sentence: "If a monster has an effect that increases the difficulty of this check, ignore that effect." could be changed.

Keeping with the theme of what adamantine does, the power should be:
"On your combat checks against a monster with this weapon, ignore the monster's resistance to Melee."

But if you want something more in line with Veteran scaling, I suggest this:
"On your combat checks against a Veteran monster with this weapon, add #."

Actions #2

Updated by keith over 3 years ago

I'm not clear what the actual argument is here.

It's not in question that it works on Werewolf/Boggard powers and Resistant, is it?

If it's more, (d/sh)ould Adamantine work on non-monster (ex: scenario, location, and hour) powers that increase monster combat difficulty #s - sure, seems reasonable. Does that need a change in wording? Maybe. I'd encourage you to include an adamantine weapon or two in Core 2, and get a good wording on it. Also, make at least one of them not a substandard defensive monk weapon.

If it's "Adamantine" should work on Veteran formula like 10+##, then... no, it shouldn't. That would be against the entire premise that let Core get away with putting Veteran on so many cards, and is antithetical to the design principles of the changes in Core+.

Actions #3

Updated by Nickademus over 3 years ago

  • Checklist item Possible insight from Keith set to Done
Actions #4

Updated by Nickademus over 3 years ago

  • Status changed from New to Pending
Actions

Also available in: Atom PDF